How To Use Website Headers For User Experience & SEO

The links in this post may be affiliate links.  That means that if you click them and make a purchase, this site makes a commission.  It will have no impact on the price you pay or the experience of your purchase.

You know that feeling when you click on an article and you’re hit with a massive wall of text?

Your eyes glaze over, you start scrolling frantically looking for… something, anything to latch onto. Before you know it, you’ve hit the back button without reading a word. I want to help you understand how to avoid being “that website” by using headers effectively.

First, think about website content like this: your content is a book, and your readers are trying to quickly find the information they need.

Without a clear title, table of contents, and chapter headings, they’ll flip through pages aimlessly, get frustrated, and put the book down.

Headers are like that organizational structure that makes a book browsable and accessible.

I’m going to be straight with you about something – most people don’t actually read web content word for word.

They scan first, then decide if it’s worth reading. Website headers are those scan-worthy signposts that help readers quickly understand what your content offers and find the specific information they’re looking for.

Here’s what’s actually happening when someone visits your page: both human visitors and search engine bots are looking for structure to make sense of your content.

When you use headers properly, you’re serving both audiences at once.

Let’s figure out how to make your headers work for you…

Header Hierarchy: Let’s Make Website HEaders Make Sense

If you’ve ever peeked at your website’s HTML or maybe within the editor, you’ve seen those H1, H2, H3 tags.

But what do they really mean?

I want you to be thinking about headers like the structure of a book:

H1: The Book Title

This is your main title – the one that tells everyone what the whole page is about.

Just like a book has only one title on its cover, your page should only have one H1.

This is the first thing both readers and search engines look at to understand what your content covers.

Example: “The Complete Guide to Organic Gardening”

H2: The Chapter Titles

These are your main sections – the big divisions in your content.

Think of H2s as the chapter titles that appear in your table of contents.

They break your content into major topic areas that a reader might browse through to find what they need.

Examples:

• “Preparing Your Soil for Organic Success”
• “Choosing the Right Plants for Your Climate”
• “Natural Pest Control Methods That Actually Work”

H3: The Section Headings

These are like the section headings within each chapter.

They break down H2 topics into more specific areas. If your H2 is “Preparing Your Soil,” your H3s would be those bolded headings throughout the chapter that divide the content into digestible chunks.

Examples:

• “Testing Soil pH at Home”
• “Organic Amendments for Clay Soil”
• “The Truth About Compost Quality”

H4-H6: The Subsections and Callouts

These are for even more specific breakdowns – like the subheadings, important callouts, or sidebar information in a textbook.

Most content won’t need to go this deep, but they’re there if you need them for very detailed or technical content.

Here’s what most people don’t tell you: headers aren’t just about organization – they create a hierarchy of importance.

Search engines use this hierarchy to understand which topics are most important on your page, just like a person skimming a book would pay attention to larger headings first.

I’ll be straight with you… skipping levels in this hierarchy (like going from an H1 directly to an H3 without an H2 in between) is like having chapter sections without a chapter title.

It confuses everyone about how information is organized.

Let me give you an example of how this works in practice:

H1: The Art & Science of Sourdough Bread (Book Title)
  H2: Getting Started with Your Sourdough Starter (Chapter 1)
    H3: Feeding Schedule for Your Starter (Section 1.1)
    H3: Troubleshooting Common Starter Problems (Section 1.2)
  H2: Mastering Basic Sourdough Techniques (Chapter 2)
    H3: Autolyse Method Explained (Section 2.1)
    H3: The Art of Stretching and Folding (Section 2.2)
      H4: Different Fold Techniques (Subsection)
      H4: Building Tension in Your Dough (Subsection)
  H2: Advanced Sourdough Recipes (Chapter 3)
    H3: Rustic Country Loaf (Section 3.1)
    H3: Sourdough Focaccia (Section 3.2)

See how this mimics the structure of a well-organized book? That’s proper header hierarchy, and it’s going to make both your readers and Google very happy.

The beautiful thing is, when you structure your content this way, you’re essentially creating a table of contents that helps everyone navigate your content efficiently.

Why Headers Actually Matter (It’s Not Just About Looking Pretty)

Let me be real about something – headers aren’t just about making your content look organized.

They serve two crucial purposes that directly impact your website’s success: they help with SEO and they make your content more accessible.

Let’s break down why this matters for your business.

For Your Human Readers

Think about the last time you were in a bookstore looking for specific information.

You probably didn’t read every book cover to cover – you looked at titles, checked the table of contents, and maybe flipped to specific chapters, right?

That’s exactly how people read online, except they’re even more impatient. Research shows that people don’t read web pages word by word – they scan.

When your content has clear headers:

• Readers can quickly determine if your page has the information they need
• They can easily navigate to the specific sections that matter to them
• They’re more likely to stay on your page (reducing that dreaded “bounce rate”)
• They’ll actually comprehend and retain your information better

Something to consider is how headers help people using screen readers. These are tools that read web content aloud for people with visual impairments.

Screen readers announce headers and allow users to navigate between them – which means properly structured headers are essential for accessibility.

When you skip header levels or use them incorrectly, you’re essentially creating a confusing experience for these users.

For Search Engines (Yes, Google Reads Your Headers)

Here’s what’s actually happening when Google crawls your site: it’s trying to understand what your content is about and how well-organized it is.

Headers are one of the strongest signals you can give search engines about your content’s structure and topic.

I want you to understandhow this impacts your SEO, so here’s why headers matter:

1. Headers signal content importance: Google pays special attention to what’s in your H1 and H2s to understand your main topics.
2. They create content hierarchy: Proper header structure tells search engines how your information is organized and which points are subordinate to others.
3. They’re prime keyword real estate: Including relevant keywords in your headers (naturally, not stuffed) helps search engines connect your content to relevant searches.
4. They improve user engagement metrics: When readers can easily navigate your content, they stay longer and engage more – signals that tell Google your content is valuable.

I always recommend thinking of headers as serving both humans and search engines simultaneously.

The good news is that what works well for one usually works well for the other – clear organization and descriptive headings benefit everyone.

Here’s the thing about SEO and headers – you don’t need to be obsessive about keyword placement, but you do need to be intentional.

Think about what someone might type into Google to find your content, then make sure those key phrases appear naturally in your headers where relevant.

Common Header Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)

I’ve seen thousands of websites in my time, and let me tell you – header mistakes are incredibly common.

But don’t worry, these are totally fixable!

Let’s look at the most frequent header mishaps I see and how to correct them.

1. The “Missing Table of Contents” Problem

This is when your page has no clear hierarchy – just a jumble of different header levels used randomly.

What it looks like:

H1: Ultimate Guide to Digital Marketing
H3: Social Media Strategies
H2: Email Marketing Tips
H4: Content Marketing
H3: SEO Basics

The fix: Map out your content structure before you write. Think like a book editor – create a logical table of contents first, then stick to it.

In the example above, all major sections should be H2s (Social Media, Email, Content, SEO), with subsections as H3s.

2. The “Multiple Book Titles” Issue

This happens when you use more than one H1 on a page. Just like a book doesn’t have multiple titles on the cover, your page should only have one H1.

What it looks like:

H1: The Complete Guide to Houseplants
*content*
H1: Caring for Succulents
*content*
H1: Best Plants for Low Light

The fix: Keep only one H1 (usually your page title), and make the others H2s. Remember, H1 is your book title, H2s are your chapters.

3. The “Formatting vs. Function” Confusion

This is when headers are chosen based on how they look rather than their hierarchical meaning. You might pick an H4 just because you like its size, even though it should be an H2 in your structure.

The fix: Remember that headers have semantic meaning – they define structure, not just appearance.

If you don’t like how your H2s look, change their styling in your CSS, don’t change their level inappropriately.

4. The “Cryptic Chapter Title” Problem

This happens when headers are vague or cute rather than descriptive.

What it looks like:

• “Getting Started” (instead of “Getting Started with Email Marketing”)
• “More Info” (instead of “Additional Resources for Social Media Management”)
• “The Secret” (instead of “The Secret to Higher Conversion Rates”)

The fix: Make sure each header clearly describes its content section and would make sense if it appeared alone in a table of contents.

5. The “Keyword Stuffing” Offense

This is when headers are awkwardly packed with keywords at the expense of readability.

What it looks like: “Best SEO Tips SEO Strategy SEO Ranking Factors SEO Guide 2024”

The fix: Write for humans first. Include keywords naturally, and only where they actually describe the content.

A good rule: if it sounds awkward when read aloud, rewrite it.

6. The “Inconsistent Style” Issue

This happens when some headers are questions, others are statements, some use sentence case, others use title case, and there’s no consistent pattern.

The fix: Choose one style for each header level and stick with it throughout your content.

For example, you might make all H2s “How to…” statements and all H3s questions.

Listen… we don’t want no problems with our headers, so we’re going to do this the right way. Think of fixing these issues like editing a book before publication – it takes a bit of effort upfront but creates a much better experience for your readers (and better results for your business).

How to Write Website Headers That Actually Work

Now that you understand why headers matter and the common mistakes to avoid, let’s talk about how to write headers that work for both your readers and search engines.

I’m a problem solver, so I’m going to give you practical strategies you can implement right away.

The Brain Dump First, Organize Later Method

When I approach header writing, I start by getting all of my thoughts out:

1. Brain dump your main topics – List everything you want to cover
2. Organize them into logical groups – What belongs together?
3. Create a hierarchy – Which points are main chapters (H2s) and which are sections within those chapters (H3s)?
4. Refine the wording – Now go back and craft compelling headers

This approach ensures your headers follow a logical structure rather than being created on the fly as you write.

The “Preview and Deeper Dive” Strategy

For long-form content, I always recommend structuring your headers to support both quick scanners and deep readers:

For scanners: Your H1 and H2s alone should tell a complete story. Someone should be able to skim just these headers and understand what your content covers.

For deep readers: Your H3s and beyond provide the detailed breakdown that rewards those who want to explore specific sections.

Writing Formulas That Work For Website Headers

There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to headers, but these formulas consistently perform well:

For H1 (Your Book Title):

• The “Ultimate Guide” Formula: The Ultimate Guide to [Topic]
• The “How-To” Formula: How to [Achieve Desired Outcome] Without [Common Pain Point]
• The “List” Formula: [Number] Ways to [Achieve Desired Outcome]
• The “Question” Formula: [Compelling Question Your Audience Is Asking]?

For H2s (Your Chapter Titles):

• The “What/Why/How” Formula: What Is [Topic]? / Why [Topic] Matters / How to [Action]
• The “Step Process” Formula: Step 1: [First Step in Process]
• The “Common Mistakes” Formula: Common Mistakes When [Topic or Action]
• The “Benefits” Formula: [Number] Benefits of [Topic or Approach]

For H3s (Your Section Headings):

• Be more specific and detailed
• Can use partial sentences or phrases
• Focus on very specific aspects of the H2 topic

The “Make It Scannable” Technique

When writing headers, I want you to make informed decisions about formatting:

• Keep headers relatively short – Aim for 60 characters or less
• Front-load important words – Put key terms at the beginning when possible
• Use parallel structure – If one H2 starts with a verb, have all H2s start with verbs
• Be specific – “How to Create a Content Calendar” is better than “Content Planning”

The “Interest + Information” Balance

The best headers combine:

• Enough information to be clear about the content
• Enough interest to make people want to read more

For example:

• Too vague: “Email Tips”
• Too boring: “Techniques for Writing Subject Lines in Email Marketing Campaigns”
• Just right: “5 Subject Line Formulas That Double Open Rates”

Before and After Examples

Here are some real header transformations to inspire you:

Remember, think of your headers like the chapter titles in your favorite non-fiction book – they should be descriptive enough that you know exactly what you’ll learn, but intriguing enough that you want to read that section right away.

Wrapping It Up: Website Headers Are Your Content’s Secret Weapon

Here’s the thing about headers – they might seem like a small detail in the grand scheme of your website, but they’re actually one of those foundational elements that make everything else work better.

Think about it like this: a well-structured book with clear chapter titles and section headings doesn’t just look more professional – it’s fundamentally more useful and accessible to its readers.

The same goes for your website content.

The Quick Takeaways

If you’re implementing header best practices today, remember these key points:

1. Structure matters – Use the proper hierarchy (H1 → H2 → H3) consistently
2. One H1 per page – Just like one title per book
3. Descriptive is better than clever – Make sure headers clearly describe their content
4. Keywords matter – Include relevant keywords naturally in your headers
5. Headers serve humans and search engines – Good headers improve both readability and SEO

Your Next Steps

I want you to make informed decisions about your content, so here’s what I recommend doing next:

1. Audit your existing content – Look at your most important pages and check if they follow proper header structure
2. Fix the biggest issues first – Focus on pages with multiple H1s or completely missing hierarchies
3. Test with real users – Ask someone to scan your content and tell you what they think it’s about based just on the headers

Need Help With Your Content Structure?

If you’re looking at your website right now and feeling overwhelmed by the header situation, don’t worry – this is totally fixable.

I’m always accessible if you have questions about your specific content. You can book a strategy session to work through it. If you need somone to write content for you, we can help with that too!

Remember: Great content that’s poorly structured is like an amazing book with no chapter titles or table of contents – the value is there, but readers might never find it.

Give your content the structure it deserves, and watch how it transforms both reader experience and search performance.